Reciprocating saws. Review, top models, comparison, reviews

Reciprocating Saw Review

The reciprocating saw is a tool that has been used for many years in the field of construction and carpentry, both in domestic and professional use. Among owners of reciprocating saws, a second name for the tool is often found: an electric hacksaw, an electric saw, a file with a narrow blade.

Reciprocating saws

The main purpose of a reciprocating saw:

• sawing plastic, wood, metal pipes, metal products;
• cutting drywall;
• pruning trees on a summer cottage;
• cutting wooden beams;
• the file can even work with materials such as porous brick, stainless steel and aluminum;
• other minor home repairs that require cutting or sawing something.

Modern models of reciprocating saws can make cuts not only in a straight line, but also change the cutting path without overheating and deformation of the blade. Modern farmers use reciprocating saws in their dachas, for the construction of wooden structures, and for small work with wood that requires great precision,

Best Cordless Reciprocating Saws

A cordless reciprocating saw is a tool with the same set of functions as a corded tool. Its only difference is its absolute independence from the network and lower performance. Such a device is more convenient to use, is not limited by distance from the power source and is relevant in the absence of electricity.

Metabo SSE 18 LTX Compact

...According to reviews of the Metabo saw, due to its compactness, it is easy to work in places where a large tool cannot reach...

Expert opinion

The TOP of electric reciprocating saws is headed by the Metabo SSE 18 LTX Compact cordless model, which is intended for sawing wood, plastic, metal and other building materials. Special fastening of the blades significantly expands the range of use of the tool. Its handle is rubberized, which prevents the palm from slipping and allows you to comfortably grip the tool. The package includes a hacksaw, a charger, and a fairly capacious 3.5 Ah/LiHD battery.

Advantages

• Lightweight;
• Convenient when working in hard-to-reach places;
• Easy adjustment of the depth stop, without tools;
• Simply monitor the battery status;
• Good illumination of the cutting area using LED lighting.

Flaws

• Does not cut wood with a diameter over 2 cm very quickly;
• No additional features;
• When working with thin sheets, they can easily break.

BoschGSA 18 V-LIC 0 L-Boxx

The BoschGSA 18 V-LIC 0 L-Boxx reciprocating hacksaw is a universal tool for cutting various materials, mainly wood and metal. It can even cut thick workpieces, since the cutting depth is 20 cm. The LED lighting on the reciprocating saw guarantees a good overview of the material when sawing. Ventilation holes guarantee excellent air distribution, which eliminates overheating and increases the life of the device. The kit includes 3 canvases, this will allow you to get started right away.

Advantages

• A special system facilitates quick replacement of equipment with one hand;
• Long-term use on one charge;
• LED backlight provides a good overview when working;
• Comfortable rubberized handle;
• High-quality control electronics.

Flaws

• The kit does not include a battery;
• High price;
• The speed cannot be changed;
• Not very good at making small diameter radius cuts;
• If the material has a high density, then you can press with your second hand only on the small protrusion of the rubber-coated gearbox.

This reciprocating saw is used for high-quality cutting of wooden blanks. Judging by user reviews, the BoschGSA 18 V-LIC 0 L-Boxx copes with such actions effectively and quite quickly. The simplicity and thoughtfulness of the design allow it to be used to carry out work with maximum convenience.

Classification

Reciprocating saws can be divided into the following categories:

• professional;
• household

These two categories, in turn, are divided according to the types of saw models:

• battery;
• network (electrical).

There are no petrol reciprocating saws in the manufacturers' product range.

Professional reciprocating saws

Professional reciprocating saws are highly powerful and can be used for a long time (up to 4 hours of continuous operation per day).

Bosch Keo reciprocating saw

Such saws have a higher cost and are designed for use in production or in carpentry shops, workshops, and repair centers. Semi-professional models also have the same parameters.

Household reciprocating saws

Household reciprocating saws are tools for home use. Files in this category can be used for a total of up to 2 hours a day.

Reciprocating saw Interskol NP-120 1010E

They are often equipped with spare saw blades due to the rapid wear of the “native” blade. Suitable for non-professional craftsmen and can be used in the household only a few times a year.

Cordless and electric reciprocating saws

Corded (electric) reciprocating saws operate directly from a network with a voltage of 220-230 Volts. Cordless reciprocating saws run on lithium batteries.

Bosch cordless reciprocating saw device

The average operating time of a household tool is 30-40 minutes, a professional one - 60-70 minutes, and then requires recharging. Almost all the world's reciprocating saw manufacturers produce both types of tools - both corded and cordless.

Which reciprocating saw is best to buy?

In order to choose the right reciprocating saw, you need to find out what materials you will be working with. It is the area of ​​use that determines which one is best suited to the master.

In addition, you need to consider what class the tool belongs to. Household models are not designed for heavy loads and long-term continuous sawing. The best ones in the price-quality combination constitute the middle segment and are good both for households and small workshops, suitable for periodic intensive use. Professional equipment with a high power reserve is always heavy and large in size. These saws are difficult to operate with one hand, suspended, in a confined space, and can be used for long periods of time in harsh construction conditions.

Characteristics

Let's take a closer look at what characteristics a good reciprocating saw should have, regardless of the connection method and operation.

Engine and power

It is logical to think that the greater the engine power of a reciprocating saw, the more productive it is. This opinion really exists among owners, but keep in mind that the more power the saw has, the heavier its weight will be.

General structure and principle of operation of a reciprocating saw

For home use, a power of up to 600 W is sufficient. For professional tasks, a saw with a power of 900 to 1700 W is well suited. The voltage parameter is also important to understand how much resources your reciprocating saw will consume.

Speed ​​or frequency

The next parameter that determines the quality of work of a reciprocating saw is the stroke frequency.

The stroke rate is the speed at which the tool can cut.

On average, for a good professional saw it ranges from 2500-3000 strokes/minute. Household tools can have stroke rates from 500 strokes/minute.

Pendulum stroke

Pendulum stroke is the ability of the saw blade to move not only along a “back and forth” trajectory, but also to rise during the reverse stroke.

Pendulum stroke of reciprocating saw

This saw operation option removes the blade from the heated area that was just sawed, therefore increasing the useful life of the tool, preventing the saw from overheating.

Overload protection

The overload protection feature automatically turns off the reciprocating saw if it overheats.

Jam protection

A special clutch can save a reciprocating saw from jamming. This option is present only in expensive models; cheap ones cannot boast of it.

Saw blade replacement mechanism

The ideal saw, according to reviews from owners, is one in which no tools are needed to change the blade and you can change it quickly, by hand. Often, to replace the blade, you need to turn a special lock or move the locking ring.

Knife replacement mechanism

On some models, the blade is additionally secured with a casing. When choosing a reciprocating saw, be sure to pay attention to the way the blade is secured.

Saw blade braking

The braking process of the reciprocating saw is carried out using an electrodynamic brake. When the start button is released, the blade stops moving. This function is the key to safe operation of the device.

Other options

Other parameters that you should pay attention to when choosing and purchasing:

• cable insulation strength;
• assembly and body materials;
• comfort of the handle, its ergonomics;
• access to carbon brushes for their maintenance;
• vibration suppression (typical of more expensive models).

The best reciprocating saws, combination of price and quality

Reciprocating saws with the best combination of price and quality can be classified as semi-professional tools. They are more productive than household ones and serve as a reliable assistant in repairs and small construction. This is an excellent alternative to a grinder - no sparks are generated when sawing, compact dimensions allow you to make cuts in hard-to-reach places. Often reciprocating saws of this class are used for car repairs and dismantling in premises with finished finishing.

Metabo SSE 1100

The model represents one of the best options in combination of price and quality. Metabo equipped the reciprocating saw with several of its own technologies: the Vibra Tech vibration damping system, Soft Start, M-Quick - quick-release chuck and keyless stop locking.

The motor and cord entry have enhanced protection against fine dust or splashes. The body is narrow and ergonomic, which ensures a secure grip even with one hand. The instrument has no unnecessary electronics, which simplifies the design and reduces cost. For bottom-up cuts, blades can be installed with a 180-degree rotation.

Advantages:

• clear and rigid fixation of thin and thick files;
• maintaining the number of revolutions and strokes of the saw;
• LED illumination of the working area;
• three stages of the pendulum;
• presence of a case for convenient storage and transportation of the tool;
• comes in a case.

Flaws:

• manual speed adjustment, rheostat button;
• no restart protection.

BLACK+DECKER RS890K

The developers of BLACK+DECKER have created a unique and very convenient reciprocating saw that looks like an inverted jigsaw. Despite its compact dimensions, the saw has very competent weight distribution and excellent balancing. It can be used for a long time with one hand or suspended. A small power of 500 W is more than enough to cut 100/100 mm timber and fell trees. The cut is smooth and clean, the smooth start reduces the starting currents - the equipment can be connected even to a low-power gas generator. The saw has three speeds with smooth adjustment.

Advantages:

• easy replacement of files by pressing one button;
• unique design – small dimensions and weight;
• great functionality;
• excellent equipment;
• three speeds.

Flaws:

• no backlight.

Hammer LZK 850 B PREMIUM

Thanks to a powerful, but at the same time quite compact engine, this reciprocating hacksaw copes with almost any household task. Changing the blade without a key, rubberized coating of the body in the grip areas, double speed adjustment - with a rheostat button and a “wheel”, significantly simplify the operator’s work. The proven design ensures tool reliability and long service life without breakage, making it one of the best reciprocating saws in its class.

Advantages:

• keyless chuck;
• good assembly;
• ease of speed adjustment;
• convenient case and accessories as standard;
• protection against accidental start.

Flaws:

• lack of pendulum motion;
• cutting large diameter materials requires skill.

Selection criteria

A good reciprocating saw should meet the following parameters:

• be powerful and productive;
• have an optimal weight for you (the higher it is, the less maneuverability of the saw);
• provide easy replacement of the canvas;
• have a quick braking function;
• have an acceptable cost and a warranty period of 1 year;
• belong to a well-known brand, which is distinguished by the high quality and reliability of its equipment.

Owner reviews of the reciprocating saw are also extremely important. Before making a purchase and choosing a reciprocating saw, we recommend reading reviews on the Internet and watching video reviews.

Buy a reciprocating saw if the comparison clearly speaks in favor of the model you have chosen.

It is also worth studying materials from farming forums and tool forums, as well as familiarizing yourself with the comparative characteristics of top models from various brands.

How to choose a reciprocating saw

A reciprocating saw is a multi-purpose tool and is most often purchased for specific purposes: gardening, dismantling, cutting building materials. The necessary parameters and functionality must correspond to the main tasks:

1. To cut various materials, you need convenient speed adjustment. It is better if it is carried out by a separate wheel.
2. For working with aerated concrete, ceramics and similar “dust-forming” materials – increased protection against dust and splashes.
3. Dismantling and work in the country often require vertical cuts from the bottom up. Therefore, it is worth choosing a reciprocating saw with the ability to install files with a 180-degree rotation or with a rotary handle.
4. Active work with wood will be more convenient if the maximum cut is more than 100 mm.
5. Sawing metal is easier if the equipment is equipped with vibration damping systems.

TOP brands for 2021

Global manufacturers of construction equipment produce reciprocating saws, annually adding new products to their lineup. Currently, the TOP brands producing reciprocating saws include companies such as Bosch, Makita, Interskol, Hammer, Metabo, DeWALT, RYOBI, AEG, Stomer.

Reciprocating saw Bosch PSA 700E

Reciprocating saw Makita JR3050T Reciprocating saw Interskol NP-120 1010E

Manufacturers Bosch, Makita, Interskol and Stomer are known for producing professional reciprocating saws. The main advantages of such equipment are high reliability, great power and endurance, as well as the presence of semi-professional models in the line and professional service.

Disadvantages include such parameters as high price and expensive components.

Metabo PowerMaxx ASE reciprocating saw

Reciprocating saw Ryobi RRS-1801M

Reciprocating saw Hammer LZK650B

Manufacturers Hammer, Metabo, DeWALT, RYOBI, AEG are known for their wide range of models, as well as inexpensive components and the ability to select a reciprocating saw for a specific task. Disadvantages of brands: they are often counterfeited by Chinese manufacturers; on the equipment market you can often find very low-quality copies of these brands.

Rating of the 10 best reciprocating saw models

Each manufacturer has top models that sell well and work stably. They are the ones who annually make it into the TOP 10 rating. Let's consider the rating of reciprocating saws included in the top best saws for the garden and home for 2021.

Average price segment of reciprocating saws

Electric models

Makita JR3050T

A well-known brand, synonymous with quality. The reciprocating saw of this model has a power of 1000 W.

Reciprocating saw Makita JR3050T

Capable of withstanding high loads. Reliable, has a long network cable; The function of quick replacement of the saw part is available, there is a smooth speed control.

Stomer SSS-1000

A classic, recognizable design familiar to several generations. Fast operating speed, power 1100 W. Smooth adjustment of operating speed, however, there is a significant drawback: the weight is more than 3 kg.

Reciprocating saw Stomer SSS-1000

The price is very good, but it is reduced due to some external details, for example, there are no rubber pads on the handle and body, the vibration is more noticeable than the first model in the rating.

AEG US 400 XE

Reciprocating saw with 400 W power. It is light in weight, very convenient to use, and suitable for indoor work where space is limited.

Reciprocating saw AEG US 400 XE

A tangible bonus: a 36-month warranty on the original product from the manufacturer. The saw is easy to use, has an average degree of vibration, and is considered the best in the category of low-power devices from AEG.

Battery models

Ryobi CR1201

Reciprocating saw with battery capacity 1.2. Popular due to its compactness, reliability, convenient design and handle.

Reciprocating saw Ryobi CR1201

There is a pendulum function, therefore, the tool is protected from overheating. Works with materials such as drywall, wood, polypropylene, ceramics, metal.

Dewalt DCS380B

Sold without battery and charger; these components must be purchased separately.

Reciprocating saw Dewalt DCS380B

Operates with a voltage of 20 V, weighs less than 3 kg, and is equipped with an electric brake. The instrument is made in classic yellow-gray tones. The design resembles the Stomer SSS-1000.

Metabo PowerMaxx ASE

A unique model in its price category. Minimum weight (1.2 kg), maneuverability, excellent build quality.

Metabo PowerMaxx ASE reciprocating saw

Equipped with a 10.8 V Li-Ion battery. Warranty service: 60 months. from the manufacturer.

Budget reciprocating saws

Continuing the rating, we note budget models suitable for low-intensity work and periodic use.

Electric models

Bosch PSA 700E

Among the expensive brothers of the model range, this reciprocating saw is the most budget-friendly.

Reciprocating saw Bosch PSA 700E

Stroke length 20 mm, can cut steel up to 1 cm thick. Tool power is 710 W.

Interskol NP-120/1010E

Reciprocating saw with a power of 1010 W, operates on a network with a standard voltage of 220 V. Weight more than 3 kg, suitable for professional use.

Reciprocating saw Interskol NP-120 1010E

It has an affordable price due to the fact that the country of origin is Russia. It has proven itself to be a reliable and powerful device.

Hammer LZK650B

The power of the saw is 720 W. Used for cutting wood and metal.

Reciprocating saw Hammer LZK650B

The tool comes with a long warranty and is similar in appearance and ergonomics to more expensive Bosch models.

Battery models

Ryobi RRS-1801M

Budget model weighing up to 2 kg. The battery must be purchased separately.

Reciprocating saw Ryobi RRS-1801M

Recommended capacity is 18 volt maximum. The stroke is 22 mm.

Rating of the 5 best electric reciprocating saws

Electric reciprocating saws are popular due to their power and ability to operate for a long time without interruption. They are mainly used in the home, workshops, and in places where it is possible to connect to a power source.

The rating includes the following models:

1. Interskol NP-120/1010E.
2. Makita JR3050T.
3. Bosch GSA 1100 E.
4. SKIL 4900 LK.
5. Stomer SSS-1000

Interskol NP-120/1010E

The Interskol NP-120/1010E saw package includes knives for working on wood and metal

. Thanks to the keyless lock, changing the blade is quick and easy. A long power cord and the ability to operate from a generator expand the range of applications of the saw. The tool is equipped with a stop for adjusting the sawing depth and a stroke regulator. For safety when working with the saw, the handle is closed with soft pads.

The price of the equipment is 4700 rubles.

Options:

pros

• safe to use;
• high power.

Minuses

• poor quality of knives included in the package.

They replaced the fence at the dacha and called a neighbor for help. He brought the “saber”. I tried to work with it and the next day I bought the same one for myself. I trimmed branches in the garden, cut metal pipes, even used it to repair a car - I did an excellent job everywhere. If you have a dacha, saw Interskol is exactly what you need.

Interskol NP-120/1010E

Makita JR3050T

Makita JR3050T is an electric saw for working with wood and metal. Equipped with a quick blade replacement system and a 4 meter long power cable. Rubber pads on the handle and body allow you to securely grip the tool with both hands. Double insulation allows the saw to be plugged into ungrounded outlets. The kit includes: a reciprocating saw, a wood saw and a metal saw.

Cost – 9300 rubles.

Main characteristics:

pros

• universal fastening of canvases;
• built-in fan for cooling the motor.

Minuses

• high cost of branded canvases.

When building a garage from aerated concrete blocks, the Makita JR3050T saw turned out to be indispensable. Even assistants were not required. At first it seemed a little heavy, but then I got used to it and things went like clockwork. I recommend it.

Makita JR3050T

Bosch GSA 1100E

Professional reciprocating saw for straight and curved cuts Bosch GSA 1100 E works on wood, metal, and drywall. The SDS system allows you to quickly change blades. The body and handle are covered with rubber and do not slip in your hands. The set includes 2 saw blades and a case for a reciprocating saw.

Price – 9800 rubles.

Characteristics:

pros

• illumination of the workpiece being processed;
• almost imperceptible vibration.

Minuses

• high price.

I do renovations and often work with drywall. Previously, it was very inconvenient to cut out shaped parts, but since I purchased a Bosch GSA 1100 E saw, the problem has not disappeared. I quickly and efficiently cut out shapes of any complexity. A little expensive, but paid for itself quickly. Now I can’t imagine working without this saw.

Bosch GSA 1100E

SKIL 4900 LK

The ideal saw from Skol for pruning trees can easily handle metal and plastic. Blade changes are quick thanks to the Clic system. The soft covering of the handle ensures comfortable operation. The kit includes: 3 blades for wood, 2 for cutting branches and 1 for cutting metal.

Price – 4040 rubles.

Main parameters:

pros

• power indicator;
• low cost (4040 rubles), unlike analogues.

Minuses

• There is no box or storage bag included.

I love working in the garden. Previously, I cut the branches with a hand hacksaw. I bought a SKIL 4900 LK electric saw and have never parted with it. Inexpensive, quiet and safe. I buy good canvases and work with great pleasure.

SKIL 4900 LK

Stomer SSS-1000

Stomer SSS-1000 is a semi-professional powerful electric saw in a metal and plastic body. Convenient to use thanks to the function of smooth speed change. The saw comes with two blades, one for wood and one for metal, a key for disassembling the tool and spare brushes. The rubberized handle and part of the body prevent slipping.

The average market price is 6,500 rubles.

Options:

pros

• ergonomic body;
• convenient blade clamp.

Minuses

• heavy weight (3.85 kg).

We started renovating the house and had to cut metal pipes. A grinder is not always suitable, so I decided to buy a new tool for the house. I chose the Stomer electric saw. I coped with the task perfectly, and now I take it with me to the dacha. An irreplaceable thing in the household.

Stomer SSS-1000

Recommendations for choosing a reciprocating saw

Of the time-tested models of reciprocating saws that have received good reviews, we can recommend the following models.

Bosch Keo

It is light in weight, runs on a battery, and copes well with tasks such as cutting branches of fruit trees and minor carpentry work.

Bosch Keo reciprocating saw

Features of this model: power and reliability combined with light weight and a low percentage of breakdowns; the only drawbacks include the need to recharge the battery, since the charge will not last long.

Bosch GSA - 10.8

A good saw for cutting wood and even metal pipes. Like the previous model, it is lightweight, only 1.2 kg.

Reciprocating saw Bosch GSA 10.8V

Features: quick replacement of the saw part, attractive design, smooth speed control, illuminated work area. Among the disadvantages, owners note the high cost and household power - more powerful models are recommended for professional use.

Best Battery Operated Reciprocating Saws

Cordless reciprocating saws are indispensable in places without electricity. These models are also convenient for roofing work and pruning garden trees at height. Despite being battery powered, the tool is highly productive and has the same characteristics as its networked counterparts. Below is a review of the three best battery-powered electric hacksaw models.

The operating time of a cordless reciprocating saw is determined by the battery capacity. For continuous sawing, you need to purchase an additional battery and choose models with gentle charging.

Metabo SSE 18 LTX Compact Box

The innovative design of the equipment lock allows you to use not only standard saw blades for reciprocating saws, but also replace them with jigsaw blades. This innovation significantly expands the capabilities of the Metabo SSE 18 LTX. Users also note the long operation of the tool until the battery is discharged and the convenient design that allows you to work in narrow spaces.

Advantages:

• light weight;
• compactness;
• system for fastening files with different shanks;
• battery unit 3.5 A/h, with charge indicator;
• Gentle charging that increases battery life.

Flaws:

• vibration when working with metal;
• There is no case as standard.

BOSCH GSA 12V-14 0

The very compact battery-powered reciprocating saw, weighing just over one kilogram, allows the operator to operate with one hand. It is equipped with a mount for quick replacement of blades, bright illumination of the work area, battery protection from overheating, complete discharge and other negative factors affecting service life. Adjusting the number of saw strokes allows you to select the required cutting speed for various materials, while ensuring maximum cleanliness and cutting speed.

The modern design of the BOSCH GSA 12V-14 0 is designed in such a way that the batteries used in it are suitable for a number of other tools from the company.

Advantages:

• very small dimensions and weight;
• the ability to saw while holding the tool with one hand;
• easy replacement of blades;
• presence of a battery charge indicator;
• long warranty;
• bright backlight.

Flaws:

• supplied without charger and battery;
• with hard materials copes with difficulty.

RYOBI R18RS-0

When choosing a good cordless reciprocating saw for your home or small construction project, you can't beat Ryobi products. The R18RS-0 model is an example of power and performance in small dimensions. The tool can easily cut through wood, plastic, rubber, and even cut steel corners with cooling. The 18 V battery is quite capacious - 5 A/h, which is enough for 2-4 hours of work at full capacity. The chuck is reliable - the equipment is tightly clamped and does not “walk” when sawing narrow or wide workpieces. The model is sold in two versions: with and without battery.

Advantages:

• performance is not inferior to network models;
• comfort in use;
• Suitable for universal batteries of the One+ series;
• there is a start block;
• changing equipment without a key.

Flaws:

• narrow lever for changing equipment;
• there is no pendulum motion.

Owner reviews

Vladimir, Kyiv region:

“The Bosch Keo reciprocating saw is not suitable for professionals, but the saw is ideal for household purposes! Despite its domestic purpose, it can be used not only for thin branches or plywood, chipboard, but also for large branches, boards, and wooden beams. It’s not very cheap in its model niche, but the quality of the brand justifies the price.”

Evgeniy, Sudak:

“The Bosch GSA - 10.8 hacksaw is excellent, you can immediately see the quality and workmanship. For powerful operations such as cutting thick boards, I would recommend a regular good grinder or chainsaw. This tool is more delicate - for thin pipes, aluminum, boards up to 2 cm thick, branches and bushes. I've been using it for two years now and have no complaints yet. There were no breakdowns. I carry out maintenance according to the instructions."

Model comparison table

Having familiarized you with the description of each of the selected models, we decided to compile a special table in which you can visually compare individual technical characteristics of the models and perhaps highlight something special for yourself.

You will be interested in: TOP 10 best snow blower: rating, which one to choose, characteristics, reviews, pros and cons