Which vacuum cleaner is better with or without a bag: with a container or an aqua filter + Video

How to choose the right vacuum cleaner?

Modern housewives do not want to run around the apartment with rags and brooms; they entrust the bulk of dry cleaning to a vacuum cleaner.
And often when choosing a device, mutually exclusive requirements arise for it. The household appliance must be powerful in order to thoroughly clean furniture and thick carpets. At the same time, to restore order in hard-to-reach corners and tight closets, you need a small, lightweight model. The problem will be solved if you buy a strong vacuum cleaner with many attachments for general cleaning, and a lightweight portable model for small daily cleaning. Read the device passport carefully. Well-known companies usually write not only electricity consumption, but also suction power. There is no need to chase a high air flow force - why do you need extra expenses if you only need to clean a small carpet and remove dust from cabinets, shelves, radiators and other hard surfaces. In this case, from 300 to 350 W will be quite enough. If you need to clean thick carpets, upholstered furniture, and also when small children or people with allergies live in the apartment, choose a brand with a power of up to 500 W.

The use of a large number of filters increases the cost, but does not improve the quality of cleaning. To avoid paying extra money, opt for 3 stages of cleaning: main dust collector, engine protection and final cleaning of the exhaust air.

Don’t forget about the optional functions that make cleaning comfortable:

bag full indicator;
variety of attachments;
telescopic tubes;
automatic cord rewinding.

You need to choose a vacuum cleaner taking into account the characteristics of both the apartment and the person doing the cleaning. A family with high incomes and a love for technological innovations can even purchase a robot. The machine will move along a given trajectory, avoid obstacles and clean the carpet without your participation. If material resources are low, the traditional model with a bag will also be a good help in cleaning. Happy shopping!

Main selection criteria

Despite all the listed disadvantages, the cyclone version of the vacuum cleaner is an excellent tool for cleaning an apartment. But the device will properly cope with its task only if it has been chosen correctly.

In order not to make a mistake with the model, you need to understand a number of technical characteristics. Let's look at each of them in more detail.

Correct calculation of suction power

First of all, you need to pay attention to the performance of the vacuum cleaner. The higher this indicator, the better the device will cope with collecting dust and dirt. Compared to their counterparts, cyclones can boast good suction power.

The high performance of vacuum cleaners with plastic containers is due to less resistance inside the bin. The air flow passes smoothly through the device, without any obstacles

For cyclone cleaning equipment, the normal suction power is considered to be 300-350 W. It is advisable to buy the most efficient devices if there are long-pile carpets on the floors in the apartment.

But know when to stop! After all, an overly powerful vacuum cleaner can damage the structure of the coating.

As for electricity consumption, the current market mainly offers models with an indicator of 1,500–2,000 W. There are also devices that use 3,000 W during operation.

Most of the electricity is spent on operating the motor and overcoming friction. In order not to make a mistake with power consumption, start from the quality of the wiring in the apartment. After all, an excessively large load can lead to damage.

Noise level and ease of cleaning

Noise level and ease of use are two interrelated technical characteristics. After all, cleaning with a vacuum cleaner, which can be compared in volume to a fighter jet, is not very comfortable. An acceptable indicator can be considered 70-80 dB.

The noise level practically does not depend in any way on the power of the harvesting equipment. Loudness is most influenced by the quality of the materials used. Also, this parameter depends on the technologies that were used to design the engine.

Convenience is far from the last place in the list of main criteria for choosing a vacuum cleaner. After all, you have to clean with the help of such equipment quite often, so it should be free from any flaws that could complicate its use.

A useful addition would be the control buttons located on the handle of the device. This will eliminate the need to constantly lean towards the body to change the power or simply turn off the cleaning equipment. The same function will be performed by the remote control.

The presence of a telescopic tube will have a positive effect on the convenience of cleaning. It will help you adjust the length to keep it at a comfortable height for you. But make sure it is made of durable aluminum.

Immediately discard plastic variations, as fast-moving debris will leave scratches on the inner surface. As a result, the service life of such a pipe usually does not exceed 1-2 years.

Equipment and types of nozzles

An important aspect when choosing a vacuum cleaner with a cyclone filter is the packaging. The more attachments the manufacturer provides, the more surfaces you can clean.

The minimum required kit includes:

classic brush;
furniture attachment;
a nozzle with a narrow tip for cleaning hard-to-reach places.

Many manufacturers, in addition to brushes, include a couple of spare filters in the box. This saves time and money. You will not need to spend money on buying new parts for the next couple of years.

If you have pets, then immediately buy a turbo brush or choose a vacuum cleaner that comes with one. This attachment does an excellent job of collecting wool and significantly improves the quality of carpet cleaning.

Dust container volume, weight and filters

When choosing cleaning equipment, do not forget about the volume of the plastic container. If it is insufficient, then you will have to empty the dust collector one or even several times during cleaning. This is extremely inconvenient, especially if you have a large apartment with many rooms.

The ease of cleaning is also affected by the weight of the unit. After all, in order to clean your home, you need to move the vacuum cleaner from place to place many times. As a rule, cyclones are not particularly heavy. In most cases, their weight does not exceed 5 kg.

The plastic container-dust collector is made of high-quality materials. Not only is it easy to clean, but it can also last a long time.

Before buying a cyclone vacuum cleaner, you need to remember that a plastic container alone will not be able to collect 100% of the dust. Therefore, the device must be equipped with an exhaust air purification system.

Models released in the last few years use HEPA type filters. They can even be found on space stations. Thanks to such filters, cleaning equipment can retain more than 99% of dust, debris and dirt.

Their only drawback is their limited service life. Due to its high density, the matter quickly becomes clogged and the cleaning system needs to be replaced every 3-4 months.

Design and quality of materials

The reliability and durability of the device depends entirely on the quality of the materials. Before purchasing a particular model, make sure that all elements are made of durable aluminum and dense plastic.

Remember that it is better to pay a little extra, but buy an assistant that will serve for many years.

Design is not the fundamental criterion for choosing cleaning equipment. But when the equipment looks attractive, cleaning becomes more enjoyable.

Today, manufacturers offer simply a huge selection of devices that differ from each other in body shape, color and decorative elements. Everyone can choose something suitable

We recommend: How to remove rodent glue if it gets on clothes or a pet

The last and for many the most important criterion for choosing a vacuum cleaner is its cost. It depends on all the characteristics listed above. The cost is especially affected by the suction power and the amount of electricity consumed.

Also significantly increasing the amount indicated on the receipt, the brand and the number of additional functions that make cleaning a little more convenient.

Features of models with a dust container

Such devices appeared in Russian stores about 15 years ago. They are equipped with a container with a cyclone filter, which is a mandatory part of the device. Unlike traditional bag devices, cyclones are more economical. There is no need to constantly buy replacement bags, so operating costs are reduced to a minimum.

Other advantages of container models are:

Such vacuum cleaners can be used continuously, emptying the container as it fills. In this case, all preparation of the device is limited to installing the dust collector in place.
During the entire cleaning, the suction power does not change for devices equipped with a multicyclone with two or more separation chambers. A vortex flow is formed in them, stabilizing the operation of the device. Moreover, the more such cameras, the more stable the system operates.
Cyclone models do not have the unpleasant odor that often occurs with bagged vacuum cleaners. In the latter, the air flow heats up and passes through all the debris remaining inside. Because of this, a specific stench appears. To prevent unpleasant odors, expensive models with odor absorbers or carbon filters are used. Cyclone models have no foreign odors.
The container design is constantly being improved. Now there are models that can compress dust into a dense briquette. This feature allows you to avoid emptying the container longer.

Engineers developing models with a container dust collector are constantly improving their designs. Now there are devices that make it possible to shake out the contents without touching the inner surface of the container. The only drawback of such devices is their high cost.

Modern models

Now there are three main types of vacuum cleaners on the market, which have fundamental differences: with bags, with a water or cyclone filter. The first technology is more than half a century old, but this does not mean that it is hopelessly outdated - such devices are still popular today. The aquafilter appeared later - in its case, the air flow passes through a container of water, so that the debris is wetted and retained. Finally, the latest innovation was the cyclone filter. This vacuum cleaner doesn’t need a bag, nor does it need water. But is it worth giving in to advertising and running for a vacuum cleaner that uses the latest technology, or can you trust a long-tested design? Let's try to analyze the advantages and disadvantages of these units in more detail.

Nuances of cyclone vacuum cleaners

Fabric and paper in the modern world are actively being replaced by plastic. Vacuum cleaners with containers have more space for shapes. They began to be produced in large and small sizes, vertical and even manual for cleaning car interiors, shelves, baseboards and small areas.

Plastic made production cheaper. A significant number of models have become more affordable due to the absence of labor-intensive materials in the design.

The cyclone mechanism works on the principle of a spiral. Vortex air currents suck in dirt at high speed. Everything settles on the walls of the flask, which can then be shaken out and washed.

Pros and cons of containers

The cyclone system also has its negative and positive aspects.
Pros:

Economical. No need to buy bags.
Fast cleaning. Emptying the bowl is much easier than cleaning and washing the bag. In addition, there is no need to dry it - you can simply wipe it dry with a napkin.
Stability in power throughout the session. The suction power is practically independent of how full the container is. The vortex movement, plus multicyclonicity, allows you to move the dust so that the air flow remains equal throughout the entire cleaning.
No foreign odor from the bowl. Incidents happen only with the cheapest low-quality raw materials, which should be avoided in any case.
Low engine wear due to overheating protection.

Minuses:

High noise level. Vortex flows move with a pronounced roar. This results in a loud sound during operation.
High electricity consumption. The increase in power also led to an increase in energy consumption.
Risk of breakdowns. A complex mechanism with many tubes can fail at the most unexpected moment. Falls and impacts are especially risky for the body, the bowl, and the engine.
High price for high-quality durable models.
Spending on filters. The container lasts a long time, but filters still have to be regularly purchased for replacement.
Periodic light electric shocks. Dust particles rub against the plastic at high speeds, creating static electricity. Sometimes you can feel a small electric shock even from the handle.
Contact with dust during cleaning.

Environmental friendliness can be called a virtue conditionally. Containers do not waste natural resources (plants, wood), but recycling plastic can create many environmental problems. The plus will be expressed only if the disposal of the used container is carried out correctly.

Flaws

In addition to the obvious advantages, such filters have some disadvantages.

Unfortunately, a large number of models of these vacuum cleaners are designed only for dry cleaning. To get more features, you will need to spend more money on a universal model of vacuum cleaner with a cyclone filter.
The weak point is the inability of the cyclone filter to efficiently collect very light and almost weightless particles, for example, fluff or hair.
These models require more electricity than analog devices. This is due to the large amount of power that the vacuum cleaner uses.
The device tends to accumulate static electricity during long-term operation, which over time begins to spread to the surface of the vacuum cleaner body. Therefore, situations of shock with this current cannot be excluded . And although this is completely harmless to health, an unexpected blow can be very unpleasant.
If large enough particles of debris penetrate into the dust collector container, the vacuum cleaner begins to make characteristic unpleasant sounds. This effect is achieved due to the fact that the trapped particles of debris begin to hit strongly against the wall of the plastic dust container. It is especially noticeable when shards of glass or some metal parts get inside.
Most models do not have air flow power regulators . And the stability of garbage suction directly depends on the power of this indicator.
An insignificant disadvantage is damage to the dust collector body due to the fact that debris penetrating inside can leave small scratches on its surface. For example, when sharp particles and parts penetrate into the dust collector.
Such vacuum cleaners are not recommended for use by people suffering from a severe allergic reaction to dust, since the process of cleaning the dust container comes into direct contact with dust.
All models, regardless of cost, are made of lightweight plastic, which significantly reduces their service life : if dropped or subjected to a strong impact, the body of the device can easily be broken.
To completely clean the container of accumulated dust and dirt, you will have to thoroughly rinse it, which is not entirely hygienic.
Vacuum cleaners often turn off automatically in the middle of cleaning. The reason for this is severe overheating of the motor and low power of the selected device model.

Read also: How to lubricate a Stihl chainsaw chain

It should be noted that modern manufacturers of this type of equipment take into account all the shortcomings of previous models and are constantly modernizing cyclone vacuum cleaners.

Washing vacuum cleaner. Which one is better to choose?

In addition to dry cleaning, wet cleaning is carried out, an expensive and pleasant pleasure. There is a function for removing spilled liquid from the floor. Operating principle: water and detergent are poured into the tank. From there, under pressure, the solution is distributed over the surface through a nozzle. The contaminated water is sucked through the holes into another tank. After each cleaning, you have to disassemble the vacuum cleaner and wash the containers.

Read how to choose a washing vacuum cleaner for your home:

buy a vacuum cleaner with adjustable volume of liquid supplied - carpet and linoleum require different amounts;
in models with vacuum nozzles, the supply of solution is controlled automatically, and the brush is able to thoroughly clean the carpet pile;
suction power for high-quality washing 400 W;
for a 1- or 2-room apartment, the optimal volume of container for clean water is about 3 liters, for a large house - up to 10 liters;
look at how convenient the location of the tanks is, which will have to be removed frequently.

We advise you to study - Izover insulation technical characteristics and properties

Advice

Ask the consultant selling the washing vacuum cleaner which method of subsequent filtration to choose. Carbon HEPA filters, class S filters, and separators are often used.

Bags: replaceable and permanent

paper breathable fabric

Textile products last for years, but do not cope with the main task very well. They retain only large dust and debris, that is, in fact, they shift the lion's share of responsibility to the remaining filters (as a result, they will have to be cleaned or replaced more often). During operation, you must carefully monitor the filling of the bag, because if you do not reset the “accumulation” in time, the suction power will deteriorate.

The rag version is not without its conveniences. A wear-resistant textile bag can (and even should) be washed, instead of immediately being thrown away - this saves the family budget.

Paper bags are much more environmentally friendly: after tidying up, they are removed from the vacuum cleaner and thrown into the trash without opening. For the next cleaning, a new bag is loaded into the body - immaculately clean and fresh. Paper (especially multilayer paper) is superior to porous fabric in terms of density, which means it retains more microparticles.

The disadvantages of paper collections follow from their advantages: regular replacement requires financial investments (albeit very insignificant), and if, due to the forgetfulness of the owners, the supply of bags suddenly turns out to be zero, cleaning will have to be postponed indefinitely.

Features of vacuum cleaners with a bag

Vacuum cleaners with a bag have been familiar to many people for decades. Unlike container ones, dust in these devices is collected in a special bag. Such devices are very “hardy”. You don’t have to be afraid to load them up: curtains, carpets, armchairs, car interior. A large scope of work is not a hindrance.

Both disposable and reusable bags are available. Disposable - made of thick paper. Their use is convenient, but not very pleasant financially. Reusable ones are made of dense and durable fabric. There is no need to get rid of such a bag after each cleaning.

Advantages of such models:

Simple and clear operation;
Possibility of adjusting the power of the device;
Huge selection of models on the market;
Easy to use bags: replacing disposable ones and cleaning reusable ones;
Possibility of irregular washing (no need to wash after each cleaning, unlike a container)

Disadvantages of vacuum cleaners with a bag:

Regular monitoring of occupancy is required;
It is possible that the reusable bag may break.

Design features of traditional bag devices

Cleaning the floor with a vacuum cleaner has become traditional for any apartment, regardless of the size of the rooms and the number of people living in it. The store often chooses bagged, traditional appliances or cyclone vacuum cleaners, where debris accumulates in a plastic container. Traditional bag devices were the first to be invented. These are the oldest models, but they are still popular.

Nowadays there are devices with two types of bags on sale:

single-use paper ones are simply thrown away after filling;
textile bags are used repeatedly after emptying.

Both types differ in their disadvantages and advantages. Before purchasing a traditional device, it would be useful to familiarize yourself with them in order to make a final decision. The price of the device, as well as the simplicity and convenience of working with it, largely depends on the type of bag used.

The vacuum cleaner bag fills quickly. Therefore, it is emptied periodically. Moreover, many owners put off this moment until the last minute, since emptying the dust collector from its contents is not the most pleasant experience. Therefore, it makes more sense to buy models with paper bags, since they do not need to be shaken out. On the other hand, additional expenses arise, since you constantly have to replenish the supply of paper consumables.

Important!

The latest generation vacuum cleaners with any bags are usually supplemented with HEPA filters, which perform fine air purification. Passing through it, the air is purified from 95% of contaminants. Therefore, such devices will be good helpers for families with children and people with allergies.

Hygiene

According to many experts, a properly made dust bag is more hygienic than a container. Multi-layer material does not easily keep contaminants inside

It becomes an important component of the filtration system. During replacement, the bag is tightly closed with a special valve.

Therefore, a person does not come into contact with dust at all.

Simplicity of design

The simple design of the bag significantly reduces the likelihood of damage to the entire vacuum cleaner. The design of cyclone models is very complex. This device has many thin channels that easily become clogged during operation. This happens especially often if large objects or wet debris are sucked in.

If handled carelessly, the container breaks or becomes cracked. Therefore, you have to change it to a new one

High power

Traditional models are usually more powerful than cyclone models. The latter lose power when passing through a cyclone. Bagged vacuum cleaners allow air flow directly. Therefore, the power remains constant and only decreases due to the filling of the bag.

Low noise level

Vacuum cleaners with bags are much quieter than their cyclone counterparts. The dust collector in such models is located under the housing cover and during operation it itself absorbs some of the noise.

Positive traits

Compared to other types of vacuum cleaners, cyclones have the following advantages:

Quite light weight;
Increased dust collection efficiency;
No need to shake out and replace dust bags;
Easy to use and no need to use a large number of attachments;
Low cost.

Rating of the best models

To purchase a powerful vacuum cleaner, you need to consider the features of each model. This will help determine which device the buyer needs. Here are some quality and safe options.

Philips FC8455

This is a compact, convenient and lightweight vacuum cleaner, weighing 4 kilograms. This is a great option for those who need a small but effective assistant. It has a large number of positive reviews from customers. The device easily reaches even the most difficult to reach corners, so it can clean the room well. There is an automatic cord rewind function; it retracts inside quite quickly and without any problems.

There is a special button on the case that will help you adjust the power. The kit includes 4 attachments that are hidden inside the unit. The volume of the dust collector is 3 liters. The vacuum cleaner has an indicator that will inform the owner that the bag is full. This option is suitable for people who need a quiet and maneuverable vacuum cleaner at a low price.

Daewoo Electronics RC-6880

This is a comfortable and lightweight model, not too big, so it will take up little space. There is a vertical parking function. The bag is small, its size is 2.5 liters. When it is full, a special sensor reports this. The cord winds up easily. Power can be adjusted.

The dust collection pipe is integral, so it can be removed if necessary. The exhaust air will be clean, since the vacuum cleaner has a fine filter that monitors its quality. This unit is very maneuverable, powerful and has a low cost. Some people note an unpleasant odor, loud noise, and that the hose may break from time to time during the cleaning process.

We advise you to study - 17 best air humidifiers - an overview of models and different types

Karcher WD 4 Premium

This is an inexpensive option that can compete with expensive models from popular brands. This is an excellent cleaner that can easily cope with cleaning a garage, home, small store and other premises. There are cartridge filters that allow customers not to worry about the quality of the exhaust air. The device can operate with or without bags. The cable is attached to the body, like other elements that are necessary during operation, which allows the owner of the vacuum cleaner to have everything necessary at hand and use it at the right time.

There are several useful attachments that make cleaning easier, such as a crevice tool, a stiff bristle brush, and a car tool. You can clean dry and wet surfaces without any problems. The dust container is quite large. The vacuum cleaner is powerful, has a 5-meter cord, and at the same time it is compact. There is a container in which you can place a variety of small items and attachments.

Samsung SC5491

This is a vacuum cleaner with high power, which allows it to suck up debris well. This is a mobile, not too expensive and simple option that will help keep your apartment clean. There is an indicator that allows the owner to know that the bag is full. The size of the dust container is 2.4 liters.

The kit includes a nozzle that allows you to remove fine lint, wool and threads (suitable for people who have pets). A high-quality filter cleans the air well. The model is lightweight and has a long cord. It should be controlled using a system located on the handle. Some reviews report that the quality of cleaning can sometimes suffer.

Bosch BSG 61800

This model is small in size and has a capacious bag with a volume of 4 liters. The dust collector is three-layered, made of synthetic material, so it can be used for several months. Those who want to save a little money can use disposable paper bags. The device is well equipped, has a long cord, and high suction power. There is no built-in HEPA filter.

Rating of the best vacuum cleaners with a bag

SAMSUNG SC5251 (noise level - 84 dB, weight - 5.4 kg): suction power is 410 W (at maximum - 1800), can be adjusted by the user. The textile dust collector has a capacity of 2 liters, the suction tube is steel, telescopic type. There is a turbo brush, a nozzle for cleaning floors and carpets, as well as a crevice and regular brush for collecting dust. Equipped with an H11 HEPA filter, a bag full indicator and an overheat protection option. The cord is 6 meters long and rewinds automatically. Double parking available.

PHILIPS FC 9071 (76 dB, 5.7 kg): Compact model with a 3-liter fabric dust bag and 450 W of adjustable suction power (2000 W peak). Supports “foot” switching on and off, complemented by a telescopic tube, a floor/carpet brush, a crevice brush and a mini nozzle for upholstered furniture (a special storage compartment is allocated). Other amenities include an aromatization function, a bag full indicator and an H13 HEPA filter. Parking can be horizontal or vertical. The cord extends 7 meters and twists automatically.

MIELE SBAD0 (80 dB, 5.8 kg): electronically controlled device with a 4.5-liter dust container (with fullness indicator). The maximum power is 1400 W, the suction strength can be adjusted. The tube is tepescopic, the set of attachments includes a crevice attachment, for upholstery, a brush and a brush for cleaning the floor - there is a special compartment for their placement. The case is shock-resistant, equipped with a foot switch and rotating rollers with a rubberized coating. An S-filter with self-cleaning is installed, there is an option for air aromatization, double parking and automatic shutdown in case of overheating. Auto-winding cord, length - 5.5 meters.

THOMAS Twin Panther (81 dB, 8.4 kg): vacuum cleaner with dry and wet cleaning capabilities. Maximum power - 1600 W (average - 320 W), bag capacity is 6 liters. A removable container is provided for the cleaning solution; dirty water is collected in a separate tank. The case is protected from impacts; telescopic tube, made of steel. The power cord stretches for 6 meters and is equipped with automatic rewind. There is protection against overheating. The set includes a microfilter, a floor-to-carpet brush, a wet cleaning attachment, a crevice brush, an upholstery brush, and a universal cleaning composition. The unit can be stored in a vertical position.

BOSCH BSG 61800 (68 dB, 5.1 kg): dry cleaning, 300 W (maximum 1800), random power switching, steel telescopic suction tube, microfilter, replaceable dust container 3.3 liters, bag full indicator (made of high quality synthetics). Includes attachments for upholstery, cleaning cracks, and cleaning floors and carpets (2 in 1). The cord rewinds automatically and is 7.5 meters long. Double parking allows you to store the vacuum cleaner both horizontally and vertically. Roller wheels rotate 360 degrees.

Vacuum cleaner with container

First, let's look at a vacuum cleaner with a container, as well as the main features of its design. It is also called “cyclone” due to the fact that the air sucked by the vacuum cleaner swirls at high speed into a spiral shape, repeating the work of the cyclone. In this case, all the dust that passes through the cyclonic air flow enters a plastic container, settling on the filter plate. This design allows you to clean up to 97% of fine dust particles from polluted air. Before getting back into the room, the air undergoes additional filtration through HEPA filters, which are capable of purifying the air up to 99.95%. However, HEPA filters, in addition to their advantages, have their disadvantages, which include their expensive maintenance. Tiny dust particles clog the pores of HEPA filters, resulting in reduced efficiency of such vacuum cleaners. Therefore, it is recommended to replace them approximately once a month with new ones. With their prices ranging from $5 to $50, this could cost you quite a bit of money.

Features of operation

Most models of vacuum cleaners with a container have an original design, and the container is most often a transparent plastic container. This is very convenient, since during operation you can observe the degree to which the container is filled with dirt.

The peculiarity of such vacuum cleaners is that the suction power does not decrease as the container is filled, as happens in bag units. After finishing cleaning, you need to remove the container, clean it of dust and adhering dirt, rinse it under running water and let it dry. Unlike bag dust collectors, cleaning the container is easy and quick. During cleaning, all dust is driven into one lump, and in some models it is even pressed into briquettes, so cleaning does not take much time.

The disadvantage is that cleaning must be done after each use, otherwise the container will become a source of unpleasant odors. Another disadvantage is that when you shake out dust from the container, you come into contact with it, which is undesirable for an allergic asthmatic. Especially for these cases, some manufacturers produce models of vacuum cleaners with the function of replacing the container with a dust collector in the form of a disposable bag. This can be very convenient not only for those who suffer from allergies, but also in other cases. For example, during cleaning you need to handle a plastic container carefully, since if it has cracks, chips or other damage, it cannot be used, and replacing it with a new one is not always possible. Also, over time, due to the ingress of sand or large debris, the inner surface of the container is grouted, as a result of which it loses its transparency. In this case, you can replace the plastic container with a bag dust collector.

We advise you to study - How to choose linoleum - nuances and selection criteria

Advantages of vacuum cleaners with a container

Lightweight and easy to maintain. The plastic container is easily removed and cleaned of dust;
Compactness. Thanks to its special design, this unit is lightweight and small in size;
Original appearance. Cyclone vacuum cleaners have an original design, and a transparent container allows you to determine the degree of filling of the container.

Disadvantages of vacuum cleaners with a container

High noise level. Due to the design features, the created air vortex inside the housing produces quite a lot of noise;
Small volume of dust collector. During cleaning, the container fills up very quickly, so in the case of cleaning large rooms, it may be necessary to empty the container several times;
Availability of HEPA filters. Not only do they require regular maintenance and replacement, which increases the cost of consumables, but they are also a breeding ground for various bacteria and a source of unpleasant odors.

Thus, a cyclone vacuum cleaner will be an excellent assistant for those who want to combine practicality of design and originality of design in their choice. It has a relatively low cost, is easy to maintain, but is not suitable for cleaning large rooms due to the rapid filling of the dust collector.

Advantages and disadvantages of vacuum cleaners with cyclone filters

Any technique has strengths and weaknesses, and cyclone-type filters are no exception.

Pros of cyclones

The plastic filter of a cyclone type vacuum cleaner is quite durable. It will not be damaged if you use household appliances to remove fragments of broken dishes or debris after repairs, which may contain nails, elements with sharp edges, etc. From this point of view, models with disposable or reusable bags are an order of magnitude less reliable.
Simplicity and hygiene of emptying the cyclone dust collector, minimal contact with its contents.
Minimum expenditure of effort and time on maintaining the filter - it is enough to periodically wash it with water.
Cost-effective – there is no need to purchase disposable filter bags or other consumables.
Stable suction power that does not decrease as dust and debris accumulate on the filter. The exception is the extreme stage of filling the container in the absence of timely cleaning or the accumulation of dust in the cyclone compartment.
Possibility of control - if you accidentally get into the vacuum cleaner the necessary small thing (parts, etc.), it will not be difficult to find it.
Improved models with a set of additional options may have additional advantages, however, their cost is usually higher than that of laconic designs.

Disadvantages of vacuum cleaners with cyclone filters

The operating principle of such a filter does not allow for the effective removal of light, almost weightless debris - pet fur and fluff, hair, threads, etc. If home appliances are required to clean such contaminants, it is better to choose a different type of model.
When the air flow rotates, static electricity is generated, which accumulates and over time can begin to be transferred to the case. By touching the body or handle in this case, you can receive a blow that is not dangerous to health and life, but a noticeable and very painful one.
The quality of work is directly dependent on the stability of the air flow. If, when cleaning upholstered furniture or curtains, the air flow decreases sharply, the centrifugal force decreases, the collected debris ends up on the filter, which leads to its rapid clogging.
When solid particles of debris enter the flow, they will knock against the walls of the chamber under the influence of the air flow, creating an unpleasant noise.
Impacts of solid particles on the walls of the chamber are also dangerous due to the appearance of microdamages on the surface. Destruction of the container is unlikely, however, transparent plastic becomes cloudy due to microscratches over time, reducing the ability to control the condition of the filter.
A compact vacuum cleaner with a cyclone filter on the handle is not suitable for thorough cleaning, and an effective full-fledged model will require significant energy consumption.
This type of home unit with a cyclone has a slightly higher noise level.

We recommend: How to wash white soles on sneakers from dirt and stains

Therefore, the pros and cons of the models, as well as reviews about them, should be considered very carefully in order to understand whether a cyclone filter in a vacuum cleaner is suitable for you or not.

Device comparison

Each type of household appliance has both its pros and cons. When choosing which vacuum cleaner to choose, you need to start from those characteristics that are important to the consumer.

You can evaluate the choice of device based on the following factors: ease of use, cleanliness of cleaning, and economic benefits.

The most convenient to use are devices with a bag, since there is no need to assemble and disassemble them before and after cleaning surfaces, or wash the container; such a device is usually compact and does not take up much space in the apartment. Containerized devices are also easy to use, since after cleaning you just need to pull out the container, shake it into the trash, and put it back. Vacuum cleaners with an aqua filter are the least convenient. After work, they must be thoroughly washed, dried and stored in disassembled condition. Large dimensions, weight, and the need to add water during operation also reduce comfort when using this type of device.

Such devices are good for general cleaning of premises with large areas. Devices with containers and garbage bags also do a good job of cleaning, but after the latter, some owners note a dusty smell. This means that the filters of such devices do a worse job and after cleaning, the particles again settle on the floors and furniture.

If we consider the purchase of a vacuum cleaner from the standpoint of economic benefit, we need to take into account both the cost of the device itself and consumables, as well as the frequency of their replacement. The most inexpensive are devices with a dust bag. But for such devices it is necessary to regularly buy bags, the average consumption of which is approximately one every 1.5-2 months. Cyclone vacuum cleaners are significantly more expensive. During their operation, there is no need to purchase additional dust collectors. The weak points of these devices are the filters, which must be purchased and changed periodically. For some models, they need to be replaced approximately every six months, for others every 5 years.

When choosing a vacuum cleaner, you need to remember that there is no right answer as to which type is best. Everyone must decide for themselves, taking into account their preferences and the characteristics of the room. For those who cannot decide which vacuum cleaner to choose, there are models that combine both types of dust collectors - a bag and a container. However, such devices are much more expensive. When purchasing, you should choose common models from well-known manufacturers, for which it will not be difficult to buy consumables, and also take into account the technical characteristics of the devices.

Comparison of characteristics

So that the buyer can reasonably decide which cleaning device is better, let's make a few comparisons.

Easy to care for and practical to use

If we consider the models from the point of view of ease of maintenance, a vacuum cleaner with a disposable paper bag has a clear advantage. This device does not need to be washed, dried the container and cleaned the filters. Once the bag is filled, simply detach it and throw it in the trash can. All preparation for work consists of inserting the bag and plugging in the vacuum cleaner. Taking into account the fact that disposable containers will have to be thrown away regularly, it is better to choose a model for which consumables can be easily found in the store. A vacuum cleaner with a universal dust collector would be an excellent option.

The container cyclone unit will have to be washed and wiped dry after each use. Otherwise, you risk introducing germs and mold into it. It's easy to do. You just need to throw the dirt into a bucket and rinse the tank under running cool water. The filter will require regular cleaning or even replacement. However, this process also does not require much effort.

Which vacuum cleaner cleans better?

From this point of view, vacuum cleaners with a container are the leaders. Even with a full dust collector, their dirt suction power does not change. While for “bag” units, the operating efficiency directly depends on how full the bag is. The fuller the container, the worse the quality of cleaning.

For rooms where dirt accumulates quickly, bagless vacuum cleaners are the best option. Their dust suction power drops only in one case - when the filtration elements located in front of the engine become sufficiently clogged. More often this happens when fairly light and long fibers become clogged with it: hair, cat hairs, threads, feathers, etc.

Which vacuum cleaner is more hygienic to use?

This question is very important, especially in cases where there are children in the house or one of the family members suffers from allergies.

It is believed that units with a bag purify the air better. The porous structure of the dust collector itself serves as an additional filter and does not allow the smallest dust particles to pass back through. The moment of truth comes when you have to clean the vacuum cleaner. It's good if the bag is disposable. You can simply throw it away, which is the most hygienic option. But if the dust collector is reusable and you have to shake it out, the pleasure drops to a level below average. There's no time for hygiene here.

Container vacuum cleaners are much better in this regard. Of course, they also have to be cleaned. But firstly, the garbage will be collected in just one cleaning, and not in a whole month, and secondly, there is no need to knock out the container, scattering dust around it. Simply rinse it with water.

Vacuum cleaners with aqua filter

In such models, the role of the container is taken on by a special flask that is filled with water. The drawn air is forced through this reservoir. As a result, all contaminants remain in the water, and clean air is discharged outside. Accordingly, there is no need to purchase garbage bags.

In terms of efficiency and degree of filtration, such vacuum cleaners can be considered almost ideal. They can be recommended to people with chronic respiratory diseases or those suffering from allergens contained in the air.

Model of a vacuum cleaner with an aqua filter

But even here it is impossible not to note a number of shortcomings:

The main disadvantage is the high cost of such models.
Large size and weight. The reservoir must be of a certain capacity.
Difficulty in maintenance. You will have to clean the vacuum cleaner after each use. Moreover, it is not enough to simply drain the water from the tank. It is necessary to rinse it thoroughly to remove any contaminants that have settled on the walls of the flask.

Which is better - a bag or a container?

Based on the considered pros and cons, you can create a comparative table of the two types of vacuum cleaners.

Characteristic	Vacuum cleaner with bag	Vacuum cleaner with container (cyclone)
Power	below	higher
Noise	less	more
Spending on consumables	more often	less often
Cleaning speed	slower	faster
Price	average	wide range for any budget
Electricity consumption	below	higher
Engine life	less	more

As for hygiene, the safest thing for the skin and respiratory system is a paper disposable garbage bag. This option is also preferable in terms of the speed of servicing the vacuum cleaner. No need to wash filters or dust collector. Simply wipe the case with a damp cloth.

Reusable filters and containers alike require cleaning and drying to prevent mold or mildew.

Price

“Bag” models are very diverse in price. Depending on the size of the buyer’s wallet, you can choose a model costing from 100 to 1,000 or more American rubles. The price of consumables also depends on the model. On average, you will have to spend an additional $2–3 per quarter, which, in general, is not much.

Cyclone vacuum cleaners cost about the same. You can find both expensive and cheap models on the market. But the price of consumables differs significantly. You will have to spend from $10 to $200 to purchase new filters, but you will have to make expenses once every couple of years or even less often.

Considering everything said above, we can say that among budget models, a vacuum cleaner with a bag is better. But if you are willing to pay more, you should choose a good multi-cyclone model. An inexpensive container-type device will not perform its functions so well, and will not work as long.

However, after assessing all the pros and cons, as well as weighing their financial capabilities, each buyer will be able to independently decide which vacuum cleaner to choose - with a bag or a container.