I encountered the problem of choosing bathroom scales immediately after being discharged from the hospital. On the one hand, it was necessary to control your own weight and monitor the process of returning to your previous shape. On the other hand, weigh the baby. I didn’t want to buy special baby scales that cost exorbitant amounts of money. On ordinary floor scales, we weigh ourselves, then with the child in our arms, we subtract the difference - we get the child’s weight. It's simple. Therefore, I was looking for scales with minimal measurement error. Read below about the difficulties I encountered and what to look for when buying bathroom scales.
- Which brand of scales is best to buy?
- Additional functions
- TOP products
- FAQ
Which brand of scales is best to buy?
My first bathroom scales were from some Chinese noname. They cost pennies and live their own lives: every time - a different result. If you plan to constantly monitor your weight and the accuracy of the results is not the least important thing, give preference to well-known brands:
- Tanita . Japanese manufacturer of products for a healthy lifestyle with a worldwide reputation. The products are of good quality and quite affordable.
- Bosh . The world's leading technology and service provider. This German company is a guarantee of reliability and quality.
- Tefal . The French company produces not only high-quality frying pans, but also small household appliances.
- Golder Electronics . A Russian company that owns the famous brands Vitek and Maxwell. A good option for those who strive for reliability, but do not want to pay extra for the “name”.
- Energy . Another Russian brand. The main advantage of their equipment is the most affordable prices.
Pay attention to the warranty. Trusted brands are responsible for the quality of their products, therefore they provide a warranty card.
Tips for choosing bathroom scales
It is obvious that the scales will delight you not only with their design, but also with their quality work, if you choose them correctly. The purchase is made after there is a clear understanding of how to use the scales.
When choosing, be sure to consider the following features of scales:
- The units of weight should be kilograms. Scales with other units must have a unit switch;
- the display should have large numbers, as this will make it easier to take weight readings;
- If you step on the scale 3 times, the readings should not differ. In this way, when purchasing, the accuracy of the readings is controlled;
- the accuracy of mechanical scales is determined by the return of the needle to the zero position after short-term pressure on the scales;
- To prevent slipping, the surface of the scale platform should be rough.
Based on the above, it should be noted that there is no clear answer to the question of which scales are best to weigh. The main thing is to decide what results you need. Users often note that even thinking about the scale makes them eat less and move more.
Which bathroom scales are best?
All floor scales are divided into 2 categories: electronic and mechanical. The latter are much cheaper, do not require batteries, but are inferior to electronic ones in functionality. The first difficulty I encountered was the presence of decoy models on the market. This means that underneath the appearance of an electronic scale with an LCD display, there is a mechanical scale hidden.
They are sold at the price of electronic ones, of course. Outwardly, they are not distinguishable, so you need to check by pressing, holding them in your hands: in hidden mechanical ones, you will immediately feel the presence of a spring, which cannot be in electronic ones. It turns out that not all things are what they seem. Be especially careful and pay attention to all characteristics when purchasing.
Weight measurement accuracy
If you don’t need special precision, you can safely take mechanical floor scales: the division price in such scales is usually 1/2 or 1 kg. Of course, it is difficult to measure a person's weight with such an error, but they are reliable, easy to use and durable.
Electronic scales have wider functionality. Good models can determine mass with an accuracy of up to 100 g; the error in simpler models is 200-300 g. At the same time, electronic devices are capable of not only measuring weight as accurately as possible, but also diagnosing the body.
Maximum load
Standard electronic scales can support weights up to 160 kg. This is quite enough for the average user. If this is not enough, you can find models with a maximum load of up to 220 kg. As for mechanics, they can withstand more weight - up to 270 kg.
Ease of use
The convenience of using floor scales directly depends on the material from which the structure is made. The combination of plastic/glass and glass/metal are the most successful in this regard. Please note that the model has rubberized legs that will provide sufficient stability on any surface. And if you, like me, use scales in the bathroom, then choose waterproof models.
Additional functions
The most popular function found in bathroom scales is the calculation of body mass index. Before weighing for the first time, you need to enter your height and the scale will automatically display your BMI.
If you are not the only family member who watches your weight, then pay attention to your memory capacity. Depending on the model, the scale can remember the weight of 2 to 10 people, and even automatically recognize the user.
The weight control feature is another important option for those who are losing weight. If you have gained a couple of extra pounds, the scale will warn you about this with a light indication or a sound signal. It’s very convenient, especially when you don’t remember down to the gram how much you weighed a week ago.
Some models can calculate the mass fraction of muscles and fat, bone tissue and fluid in the body. Such diagnostic scales have built-in electrodes that release a weak discharge of electricity. Depending on the tissue response to the impulse, data are calculated by fraction.
Availability of backlight
The backlight function is very ambiguous. It is really only necessary if you are weighing yourself in the dark and cannot turn on the light. Plus, the backlight drains the scale’s batteries faster.
Electronic balance
Electronic bathroom scales
Unlike mechanical scales, in electronic scales the weighing result is not displayed on a measuring scale with numbers, but is displayed using a digital display. Readings on electronic scales also have a certain division value. The discreteness of readings in different models of scales can vary from 0.1 to 0.5 kg. The principle of measuring weight in electronic scales can be different, depending on whether they contain metal parts and which ones.
The very first electronic scales were no different in weighing principle from mechanical scales. They had the same measuring spring, only the weighing result was displayed on a digital display. More complex electronic scales have two metal disks in their design, forming something similar to an electrical capacitor. At the slightest impact on the scales, the plates move apart, the electrical charge between the plates changes, and this in turn affects the weight readings. At the same time, the use of mechanical elements is minimized, which increases the reliability and durability of the scale design.
Finally, the most advanced scale models use a voltage sensor. A voltage sensor is a thin metal wire through which an electric current is passed. Under the influence of weight, the voltage sensor is tensioned, the electrical signal passing through the wire changes, and the readings of the measured weight on the digital display change accordingly. In scales with this design, mechanical elements are completely absent; all measurements are carried out only using electronics.
To operate electronic scales, batteries with a voltage of 1.5 V or 9 V are usually used. But some models of scales are powered by solar panels or energy accumulated from mechanical impact on the scales. Almost all electronic scales turn on and off automatically. Setting the “zero” in electronic scales is carried out automatically when they are turned on or using a special button on the case. Thanks to its intelligent filling, electronic scales have many additional functions.
TOP products
I have compiled a rating of both electronic and mechanical floor scales, based not only on standard parameters, but also reviews. I hope that it will be as useful and informative as possible for you.
The best floor diagnostic scales
Tanita BC-730 RD
A scale with analytical capabilities that can measure 7 indicators in addition to total weight: BMI, bone and muscle mass, percentage of water and visceral fat, metabolic age and required number of calories.
The model is distinguished by a special program intended for children. The device’s memory is designed for 5 users. The maximum load is 150 kg, measurement accuracy is up to 100 g. The platform is made of metal and durable plastic.
The only drawback that users note is the price of the scales (~ $41.5). But taking into account the functionality of the device, it is completely justified.
Price RUB 2,739
Bosch PPW 3330
Diagnostic scales with glass housing. Among the main functions are determining the level of water and subcutaneous fat, muscle and bone mass. The scales can withstand loads of up to 180 kg, the measurement error is only 100g. The built-in memory is designed for 10 users, there is a special measurement mode for athletes. Turns on and off automatically.
Among the shortcomings, it is worth noting a peculiar inclusion: the scales do not respond to touch or foot pressure, but to vibration. You need to slap them sharply with your fingertips to turn them on, which not every user succeeds the first time. The cost of the scales is ~ $34.5.
Price RUB 2,610
The best electronic bathroom scales without diagnostics
Tefal PP1060
Inexpensive classic black electronic scales, made in a glass case. They can withstand weight up to 150 kg, the measurement error is only 100 g. There is a display backlight, as well as an indication of overload and low battery.
The result disappears from the display if you leave the scale. This is the main drawback of the device. In total, the information remains on the screen for 10 seconds. If it is necessary to measure weight up to 10 kg, the scales do not respond and show 0. Product cost ~ $ 14.8.
Price RUB 1,590
Tanita HD-380WH
Electronic floor scales with 5mm thick tempered glass housing. The model is compact, with a large display and large, clear numbers. The maximum load is 150 kg, measurement accuracy is up to 100 g. Backlit display, automatic on and off. The scale supports kg and English feet; you can change units of measurement using a button located on the back of the case.
Among the features, it is worth highlighting the requirements for an absolutely flat surface during measurements, otherwise the result may jump by 2-3 kg. An important drawback that users note is the inconvenience of turning on the device. This model turns on only if it is lifted around the corner and lightly hit the floor. Does not respond to touches, pressing and tapping with the foot or reacts only once. Cost is ~$16.
Price RUB 1,481
The best mechanical bathroom scales
Energy ENM-408E
Classic, inexpensive, no-frills floor mechanical scales from a Russian manufacturer, simple and easy to use. The platform is made of durable plastic and can withstand loads of up to 120 kg. The design of the scales is made in sand color with the image of a palm tree.
The division price is 1 kg. Among the disadvantages are errors of 2-3 kg when measuring on different surfaces. Users notice that even the position of the body when weighing affects the result. Otherwise, it’s a reliable, durable and budget device, costing ~$6.1.
Price RUB 413
Maxwell MW-2656 W
A mechanical model of scales with a stable platform made of non-slip material and a laconic body shape. The model is equipped with wide rubberized legs that hold the scales on a smooth surface, so you can safely use them even in the bathroom. Maximum load - 130 kg, division price - 100 g.
Among the disadvantages, users note the need to tighten the wheel after 3-5 weighings. Like all mechanical scales, this model has problems with accuracy on uneven surfaces. The problem is solved by using a small disc in the front: this is how the error is minimized. The cost of the device is small ~ $13.3.
Price RUB 890
Advantages of electronic scales over mechanical ones
The advantages of electronic scales include the following. Measurement accuracy. We have already mentioned that the error of electronic scales ranges from 5 to 10 grams. This is important for people who strictly control their weight from day to day.
Multifactorial measurements. The latest models of scales allow you to measure not only body weight, but also the percentage of bones, fat and muscle tissue. This is achieved by measuring the body's electrical potential. This type of scale is not recommended for use by children under 10 years of age, pregnant women, or people with heart or brain diseases.
Availability of memory of previous weighings. Using this function, you can track the dynamics of your body weight over time. You can also track changes in the balance of fat and muscle mass over a certain period of time. Availability of user identification.
Before the first use, you create your profile, describing the main parameters - age, height and others. As soon as you step on the scale, it automatically detects your identity and sets the appropriate settings and parameters. Determination of body mass index. This value determines the degree to which your body weight matches your height and build. You enter your basic parameters, and the microprocessor automatically calculates this index. Availability of automatic shutdown function.
This option allows you to save battery life by turning off the device in case of prolonged inactivity. Some models are equipped with a wireless monitor that allows you to read body parameters without bending over or confusing the readings of the device. “Fresh” models can connect to a PC. Availability of a clock, thermometer and choice of convenient units of measurement.
Comparison chart of the best bathroom scales
| Name | Main characteristics | Price |
| Tanita BC-730 RD | Diagnosis of fat mass, muscle mass, fluid, bone tissue, optimal weight Weight change graph User definition Automatic switching on | ₽ 2 739 |
| Bosch PPW 3330 | Mechanism: electronic Maximum load (kg): 180 Graduation value (g) 100 Automatic inclusion Platform material: glass | ₽ 2 610 |
| Tefal PP1060 | Maximum weight 150 kg Measurement step 100 g Batteries CR2032 x 1 pc (included) Additional functions Automatic switching on Display with 23 mm digits | ₽ 1 590 |
| Tanita HD-380WH | Liquid crystal display Display size: 65x35 cm Display: 32 mm height of digits Automatic calibration Automatic switch-on Indication of exceeding permissible load | ₽ 1 481 |
| Energy ENM-408E | Mechanical scales Platform material plastic Maximum load 120 kg Graduation value 1000 g | ₽ 413 |
| Maxwell MW-2656 W | Mechanical scales Maximum permissible weight: 130 kg. Graduation value: 1000 g. Large font of inscriptions on the scale. | ₽ 890 |
Pros and cons of electronic and mechanical devices
The advantages of mechanical scales include:
- Favorable cost;
- The devices do not have batteries or batteries, so there is no need to constantly change them;
- Easy to use: do not require switching on or setting up;
- Guarantees long-term operation when used correctly;
- Sturdy construction;
- Can be stored anywhere.
The disadvantages buyers include:
- Poor accuracy;
- Low functionality - fat mass cannot be calculated;
- The operating mechanism is outdated - the scales were developed back in the Soviet Union.
Buyers include the following advantages of electronic devices:
- Excellent accuracy;
- Modern appearance;
- High functionality, making it easier to lose weight.
Unfortunately, they also have a number of disadvantages:
- High price tag for devices;
- A number of storage and operation requirements to keep the device intact;
- The scale contains a battery or batteries that will need to be replaced.
Based on the above, we can draw a conclusion. Mechanics are perfect for people who don’t want to count every last detail and don’t want to deal with instructions and settings. Electronic devices are needed for those who consider thorough measurement accuracy important and put a healthy lifestyle in first place.
FAQ:
Which bathroom scales are best for weight control? To control your weight, it is better to choose electronic models with a function called the weight control function. The scale will report your weight gain with a beep.
Which scales are more accurate: electronic or mechanical? The error in mechanical scales is 1 kg, and in electronic ones up to 100 g. With proper operation and timely replacement of batteries, electronic scales will be more accurate.
Ordinary floor scales for the body can show a small weight of one or two kilograms? Depends on the model. Most scales show weight from 2-5 kg and above. If you need to measure a smaller weight, take it in your hands and weigh yourself with it, and then without it. By simply calculating the difference you will get the desired weight.
How to choose
When the purchasing decision is made, pay attention to the following characteristics of bathroom scales:
- The measurement system is most often kg and pounds.
- Check with your consultants to find out what errors are stated by the manufacturer of the model you have chosen.
- Make a choice in favor of a metal case: it is more durable and practical than plastic.
- When purchasing a mechanical measuring device, make sure that the spring inside the structure is intact. To do this, press firmly on the platform and release sharply; the arrow should instantly return to zero.
- If you have poor eyesight, get a model with large numbers.
- If you are going to store the scale in the bathroom, it is better to choose a model with a waterproof case.
- The device platform is much more practical if its surface is rough or embossed and its bottom is rubberized.
Don’t chase expensive models; stop looking at high-quality and most accurate floor scales that have the optimal set of functions and characteristics for you.
